Another venue bites the dust thanks to PLCE - Castle Pub

Discussion concerning legal issues affecting live and recorded music in PA.

Moderators: Ron, Jim Price

User avatar
Ron
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 2034
Joined: Saturday Dec 07, 2002
Location: State College, PA

Post by Ron »

lonewolf wrote:Retro, here's another alternative:

http://www.pacode.com/secure/data/040/c ... s5.36.html
That is an option for The Castle.

I can see where local municipalities would balk at the idea of waiving enforcement by the BLCE. A lot of PA municipalities don't even have local law enforcement, and the petition to waive BLCE enforcement requires that the municipality show intention to enforce the ordinances. If there is no local police force, I'm sure that no waiver would be granted.

Dean, I would try to contact the Ebensburg mayor/manager/borough council and see if they are receptive to waiving BLCE enforcement and adopting a sane noise ordinance. Heck, you probably already know them.
http://www.ebensburgpa.com/ebensburg/ta ... xonomy.asp
... and then the wheel fell off.
User avatar
Bert|Evil
Platinum Member
Platinum Member
Posts: 590
Joined: Wednesday Apr 20, 2005
Location: Sesame Street 2: Electric Boogaloo

Post by Bert|Evil »

What motivates the Commonwealth of PA in these witch hunts that are so reminiscent of Holy Roman Empire societies? Do the monies from DUIs, liquor control gestapo raids, and underage drinking fund all of the misappropriation (asphalting the same roads in a yearly basis, over-funded service organizations, etc.) that the Commonwealth refuses to become more efficient upon? Is it that the Commonwealth receives revenue for State Stores that serve alcohol, but yet they pay the salaries of the state workers who man them?

Will the two examples that I’ve listed be the only reasons to why we will not face another prohibition? Once you’ve lived in other commonwealths, you will easily see just how draconian Pennsylvania is!

BERT FOR PRESIDENT!!!!!!!!!!
User avatar
lonewolf
Diamond Member
Diamond Member
Posts: 6249
Joined: Thursday Sep 25, 2003
Location: Anywhere, Earth
Contact:

Post by lonewolf »

Bert|Evil wrote:What motivates the Commonwealth of PA in these witch hunts that are so reminiscent of Holy Roman Empire societies? Do the monies from DUIs, liquor control gestapo raids, and underage drinking fund all of the misappropriation (asphalting the same roads in a yearly basis, over-funded service organizations, etc.) that the Commonwealth refuses to become more efficient upon? Is it that the Commonwealth receives revenue for State Stores that serve alcohol, but yet they pay the salaries of the state workers who man them?

Will the two examples that I’ve listed be the only reasons to why we will not face another prohibition? Once you’ve lived in other commonwealths, you will easily see just how draconian Pennsylvania is!

BERT FOR PRESIDENT!!!!!!!!!!
I doubt if Rendell knows anything about it. It looks like the Altoona office is a rogue group on its own crusade. The Altoona office covers a pretty big area, including Blair, Bedford, Cambria, Huntingdon, Centre and others. Thats where all of the noise busts have been.
...Oh, the freedom of the day that yielded to no rule or time...
User avatar
Mackovyak
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 340
Joined: Monday Dec 09, 2002
Location: Annapolis, MD
Contact:

that sucks

Post by Mackovyak »

Sorry to hear that Dean,
I've always like hitting the Castle Pub. What sucks worse is the other people who are suffering along with the Musicians and Bar Owners...

The Bar Staff (college kids, bartenders, bouncers, sound guys, ect)

also the local music shops, recording studios, ect ect.


A question for those in the radio industry.....

If a grassroots organization would purchase radio airtime for a commercial about this, what would it cost? Sort of like the Truth ads for cigarettes on T.V. ??

What I'm getting it is that the Altoona area is very much blue collar and many people don't know this is going on unless they are well into the music scene. Especially b/c their not complaining. Why not put some public pressure on the PLCB by bringing it to the attention of the public that they are now taking matters into their own hands when there's not really a public outcry against these live music.

I don't know, just a thought.
www.seventides.net

On a pillow of your bones
I will lay across the stones
Of your shore until the tide comes crawling back
User avatar
Bert|Evil
Platinum Member
Platinum Member
Posts: 590
Joined: Wednesday Apr 20, 2005
Location: Sesame Street 2: Electric Boogaloo

Post by Bert|Evil »

The more $$$$ that dump into your club, the more that you interest the PLCE. Anyways, that would seem to be the trend.

Shooters, Castle, etc.
User avatar
Bert|Evil
Platinum Member
Platinum Member
Posts: 590
Joined: Wednesday Apr 20, 2005
Location: Sesame Street 2: Electric Boogaloo

Re: that sucks

Post by Bert|Evil »

Mackovyak wrote:Sorry to hear that Dean,
I've always like hitting the Castle Pub. What sucks worse is the other people who are suffering along with the Musicians and Bar Owners...

The Bar Staff (college kids, bartenders, bouncers, sound guys, ect)

also the local music shops, recording studios, ect ect.


A question for those in the radio industry.....

If a grassroots organization would purchase radio airtime for a commercial about this, what would it cost? Sort of like the Truth ads for cigarettes on T.V. ??

What I'm getting it is that the Altoona area is very much blue collar and many people don't know this is going on unless they are well into the music scene. Especially b/c their not complaining. Why not put some public pressure on the PLCB by bringing it to the attention of the public that they are now taking matters into their own hands when there's not really a public outcry against these live music.

I don't know, just a thought.
Good point!! As I mentioned in an earlier post, it would appear that we're on our way to another prohibition (if you never mind the $$$ that the state makes out of all of this). Why not have some anti-PLCE T-shirts, bumper stickers, and commercials on our way to the speak-eazy clubs.
User avatar
Jim Price
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 4825
Joined: Saturday Dec 07, 2002
Location: Altoona, PA

Post by Jim Price »

Mackovyak wrote:
A question for those in the radio industry.....

If a grassroots organization would purchase radio airtime for a commercial about this, what would it cost? Sort of like the Truth ads for cigarettes on T.V. ??

What I'm getting it is that the Altoona area is very much blue collar and many people don't know this is going on unless they are well into the music scene. Especially b/c their not complaining. Why not put some public pressure on the PLCB by bringing it to the attention of the public that they are now taking matters into their own hands when there's not really a public outcry against these live music.
I'm not sure about the cost of airtime on my station for such spots (I don't deal with the advertising/rates side of it, I just do the on air thing); but if a grass roots organization were to come together to fight this issue, heightening public awareness about the problem and its harmful effects could bring some outcry.

If an organized effort were to come together, I could mention it on the "Backyard Rocker," particularly if the organization schedules meetings or other events that could be publicized as news items or PSA's.

You can also generate publicity about the problem with letters to local newspapers (I had one published last winter, which brought an email response directly to me from a state police official who thought I was merely a mouthpiece for a club that got busted). You can also call in local radio talk shows (WRTA from 9 AM to 11:45 AM) to stir discussion and let people outside the local music scene know what is going on.

I'm not sure what effect the publicity would ultimately have. I know a few years ago, when the state police LCE barred teens from attending the Lakemont Park Wing-Off's, public pressure on the PLCB through letters and publicity resulted in the PLCB telling the local state police to reverse their decision and let teens attend the Wing-Off's. That situation impacted children, which can get people fired up pretty quickly. I'm not sure this situation would generate the same sense of urgency with the public. Public outcry and pressure could work, or it could just give the state police a black eye and piss them off more (resulting in more crackdowns?). And I'm not too hopeful about our state legislators taking an interest, based on their past response to our efforts (and how concerned can we expect them to be about us when they just voted themselves a pay raise?).

An idea I'm considering is drafting a letter to the American Federation of Musicians (AFM), to explain the situation to them, and solicit feedback from them about how we might go about addressing this problem. Perhaps they have dealt with similar situations before in other parts of the country, and might have some wisdom or advice about what course of action we might take.
User avatar
redawg
Retroactive Member
Retroactive Member
Posts: 469
Joined: Sunday Jul 13, 2003
Location: Walking On Sunshine

Post by redawg »

My favorite job in the world is/WAS running sound and lights for bands. Now it's gone :x :x :x :evil: :evil: :evil: :( :( :( :? :shock: :cry: :cry:
User avatar
HurricaneBob
AA Member
AA Member
Posts: 2790
Joined: Monday Dec 09, 2002
Location: /root/2/pub
Contact:

Post by HurricaneBob »

We need someone on the inside...this is just gestapo crap. One mans say against a club and musicians without a complaint. Theres got to be a loophole somewhere, good searches Ron!
User avatar
getclosertothemusic
Gold Member
Gold Member
Posts: 237
Joined: Saturday Apr 24, 2004
Location: Tyrone,PA.
Contact:

this will affect everyone

Post by getclosertothemusic »

JP you mentioned about the Lakemont Park Wing Off thing and how it affected the kids, the will too. It will discourage kids from getting involved in the music scene. If they feel that there is no future in this area for live local music, they aren't going to get involved. We can't let that happen. We MUST at least try to do something to help this situation. I'm like Griff, I don't have any ideas on how to do this, but we will be monitoring this and will be willing to help any way we can.

Cathy & Ed
GCTTM
Give the kids an instrument and let their minds explore!
http://www.getclosertothemusic.org
http://www.myspace.com/getclosertothemusic
User avatar
Jerry C
Active Member
Active Member
Posts: 89
Joined: Thursday Nov 25, 2004
Location: Northern Cambria, Pa.
Contact:

Post by Jerry C »

Hey Dean,
Sorry to hear this. The Inmates always had a great time at the Pub. A citation without a complaint is profiling a business and is ridiculous. It is total discrimination!! Maybe that word should be used more. I know an owner who was to have acoustic music on an outdoor patio, with no one for miles around, and was threatened to be fined by th LCE if they did. They can't be allowed to continue like this.
If you book them, they will come..... Night Train Rocks!!!!!!!
www.nighttrainrocks.com
www.jerrysfault.com
Post Reply